CLEAR Goals vs SMART Goals: Which Strategy is Best for You?

Creating goals is important in order to reach success in both personal and professional realms. However, you should know that different goal-setting strategies can yield different outcomes.

Two popular methods are CLEAR goals and SMART goals. While both approaches have their merits, determining which best fits your personalized needs may be tricky.

In this article, we will cover the differences between SMART and CLEAR goals and help you decide which strategy is right for you. We will examine the principles, benefits, and limitations of each goal-setting framework.

We’ll also provide some practical tips and how you can apply each system to real-life scenarios. You’ll have a comprehensive understanding of both frameworks, allowing you to decide on which goal-setting method to use.

What Are CLEAR Goals?

CLEAR (Collaborative, Limited, Emotional, Appreciable, and Refinable) is another popular goal-setting methodology. It combines elements of the SMART system, emphasizing creativity and collaboration.

Each step in this approach is as important as the next to ensure success. Here’s a breakdown of each criterion:

  • Collaborative: Encourage open communication and group participation in the goal-setting process. That will ensure everyone involved has a shared understanding of the objectives and how to best reach them.
  • Limited: Narrow your goals so they are not too broad and overwhelming. Remember to focus on the most important ones you have in mind.
  • Emotional: Find a way to make your goals meaningful and emotionally engaging. That way, you will feel motivated to stay on top of the task and remain committed.
  • Appreciable: Break down your goals into smaller, more attainable steps. You want to have a sense of accomplishment as you reach each milestone.
  • Refinable: Be bold and adjust your goals as needed. This should allow you to learn from your mistakes and remain agile in the face of change.

The CLEAR system is an excellent way to organize yourself and your team. It allows you to stay focused while allowing room for growth and adaptation.

What Are SMART Goals?

SMART (Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, and Time-based) is a goal-setting technique to help individuals and organizations aim high while remaining realistic.

This approach allows people to identify achievable targets while challenging them to reach for something greater.

Need more clarity? Here is a deeper explanation of each criterion:

  • Specific: Your goal should be as specific as possible. This includes knowing the details of your target, such as who is involved and what results you expect to achieve.
  • Measurable: It is important to track results, so ensure you have a way of measuring the success of your goal. This criterion will enable you to progress steadily along the journey.
  • Attainable: Without attainability, you may get discouraged and give up. So remember to ensure the goals are realistic and achievable within a given time frame.
  • Relevant: Be sure your goal is relevant to the current situation and context in which you work. Otherwise, it won’t be easy to maintain your energy over time.
  • Time-based: It is crucial to have a well-defined timeline for setting goals. Creating an end date will help you act without delay by adding a feeling of urgency.

Using the SMART method is essential to accomplishing your dreams. And the process doesn’t need to be entirely complicated.

To ensure lasting success, specify your desired outcome and the deadline you have in mind. A concrete plan will bring clarity and organization to your life while keeping you responsible.

Pros and Cons of CLEAR Goals

Pros of CLEAR Goals

  • Setting CLEAR goals are less intimidating than SMART goals. The 5-step framework provides an easy way to progress without the pressure of achieving predetermined outcomes.
  • The CLEAR system encourages collaboration. It provides a common language that enables teams to work together and coordinate their efforts more efficiently.
  • It is easier to modify CLEAR goals. If your target is unclear or something unexpected arises, you have the freedom to adjust and improve your strategy. Overall, the refinable criterion of CLEAR makes it easier to change than other goal-setting tools.
  • CLEAR goals allow for more creativity. Brainstorming and developing alternative solutions is easier when you don’t have to confine your ideas to strict criteria.
  • CLEAR goals remind you why you’re aiming for success in the first place. It’s essential to stay connected to your intentions to maintain your motivation.
  • The CLEAR method is motivating since they create a vision of the future. The clarity aspect allows you to visualize the end result, making it easier to remain inspired.

Cons of CLEAR Goals

  • The CLEAR approach may be too vague for some people. Having the freedom to make changes can be seen as unfavorable by those who don’t like ambiguity or prefer structure.
  • CLEAR goals can require more effort. You may need to constantly assess and evaluate your progress to adjust accordingly. And if it’s your first time setting this type of goal, it could be incredibly challenging.
  • CLEAR may be difficult to explain and implement. Explaining the process can be time-consuming, taking extra steps to get everyone on board with this approach.
  • Pursuing CLEAR goals doesn’t necessarily guarantee success. Even if you’ve thought through all the steps and have a well-defined plan, it’s still possible that something may go wrong. And since you’re allowed more flexibility with this tool, it’s more arduous to pinpoint the exact cause of failure.
  • The CLEAR system isn’t the most suitable for the short term. This strategy emphasizes gaining an understanding of your core values and aspirations. Hence, it’s best suited for more profound goals. So if you seek immediate results, this methodology might be ineffective.

Pros and Cons of SMART Goals

Pros of SMART Goals

  • The SMART template is a helpful tool for timely outcomes. Clarifying your goals beforehand enables you to manage resources effectively and concentrate on reaching success on time.
  • SMART goals are highly adaptable and can encompass any area of life. They can relate to various situations and contexts, from career growth to project management and financial planning. The versatility of SMART is what makes them so popular.
  • SMART fosters specificity by encouraging you to provide more details. This goal-setting approach assists you in dividing your tasks into more achievable parts that you can complete separately. The instructions will be clear, and you won’t be left confused.
  • You’ll make your goals more actionable by adhering to the SMART criteria. It’s important to focus on the necessary action and take the initiative. You will have the opportunity to strive towards meeting your desired outcome.
  • Crafting SMART goals can enhance your feeling of accomplishment. Every time you complete a milestone, you can celebrate victories that will boost your enthusiasm even more.
  • Setting SMART goals provides inspiration for you. It becomes easier to remain energized and steadily progress toward greatness rather than procrastinate on your tasks.
  • SMART goals discourage impractical aspirations. These goals allow you to evaluate your abilities realistically and inspire you to strive for excellence with ambition and persistence.

Cons of SMART Goals

  • Some people may find SMART goals too inflexible. You would have to personalize the framework according to the individual’s abilities. Otherwise, it may be too harsh or limiting.
  • There is no guarantee of success with the SMART method. Sometimes, ticking off each requirement does not guarantee success, even though it may seem that way. While achieving goals can improve confidence and motivate you to keep going, there is always a risk of failure involved.
  • Strategizing SMART goals requires significant time and effort. Getting results quickly should not be expected when embarking on this journey. It would need diligence to sit down and think through your objectives.
  • Setting SMART goals doesn’t mean the work is done for you. Attaining the ideal outcome depends on variables like motivation and focus, which you must consider. After all, it may be possible that you don’t have enough persistence to fully dedicate yourself to the pursuit.
  • SMART goals do not encourage taking breaks. Consistently pushing yourself could be harmful and lead to burnout or fatigue. So relaxing is very important for taking care of your mental health later down the line.

When to Set CLEAR and SMART Goals

When setting meaningful and achievable goals, both CLEAR and SMART methodologies have their advantages. Make sure you consider each approach and determine which works best for your unique situation.

When to set CLEAR goals:

  • You seek to inspire and motivate yourself or others
  • You desire a goal that can be collaborated on with your team
  • You’re hoping to challenge yourself in brand-new ways
  • You are looking for a sense of purpose and connection in your work
  • You want to explore different possibilities and take risks
  • You need to be emotionally and intuitively driven by your goals
  • You’re leading a team and want to ensure everyone is on the same page
  • You want to avoid misunderstandings about what must be done
  • You want to communicate your progress to others within your company

When to set SMART goals:

  • You want to celebrate each small accomplishment
  • You need a deadline in place to foster accountability
  • You are looking for a goal that is both achievable and precise
  • You need to break down complex goals into smaller tasks
  • You need to be able to promote growth in all areas
  • You strive for a culture of self-discipline and organization
  • You want to focus and prioritize your efforts efficiently
  • You hope to align your goals with your overall vision

Dedication and commitment are important, no matter your goal type. Develop a strategy and begin making progress towards accomplishing it.

Recognize that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to goal setting—individuals should find what works best for them and their values. With the proper attitude, success is just a few steps away.

Final Thoughts

Both SMART and CLEAR methods can help you develop practical goals. While the SMART framework emphasizes specificity, the CLEAR framework prioritizes collaboration and emotionally-driven action.

Ultimately, deciding which approach best aligns with your goals and objectives is up to you. Consider personal preference, time constraints, and available resources before adopting a technique.

Remember that setting goals is an ongoing process, and you may need to reevaluate and adjust them regularly. Above all, try to learn from setbacks and stay energized to meet your desired targets. Your dreams will no longer be far-fetched.

Photo of author

Rei Shen

Rei is the founder of Success in Depth. Based in Washington, he graduated with a bachelor’s degree in Computer Science. He brings years of experience in goal setting to empower readers to reach their aspirations.